top of page
  • Writer's pictureSophia Satapathy

Is Flipkart's Compensation of Rs. 10,000 Enough for Unfair Cancellation Practices and Mental Harassment?

Updated: Apr 4



flipkart scam thumbnail

Imagine the unease that arises when you eagerly await the arrival of an important delivery, only to have it unexpectedly canceled. That happened to one customer who was awaiting his new iPhone order from Flipkart. Just days before the scheduled delivery date, he received a shocking SMS saying the company had canceled his order.

Confused and disappointed, he contacted Flipkart, which claimed the delivery agent couldn't take the phone because he wasn't home. But the customer insists he was available and in touch with Flipkart, giving them chances to solve the issue. Something wasn't adding up in this cancellation.

As the customer soon discovered, the real reason was even more frustrating. The consumer court found that Flipkart had intentionally canceled his order to profit from a price increase of around Rs. 7,000 on the iPhone model. Deeming this an unfair trade practice that caused mental harassment, the court ordered Flipkart to pay the man Rs. 10,000 in compensation for their troubling actions. This is a lesson for companies on the importance of fair treatment of customers.

Background of the Case




In July 2022, a customer ordered an iPhone from Flipkart and paid Rs. 39,628. However, after a few days, Flipkart canceled the order.

The customer was very disappointed as he was looking forward to getting the new iPhone. When he asked Flipkart about canceling the order, they said the delivery boy could not deliver it because the customer was unavailable. But the customer said this was not true.

The cancellation caused the customer mental stress and frustration. He filed a case against Flipkart in the consumer court. Let's see what the consumer court decided in this case.

Customer's Grievances around Unfair Cancellation

The customer filed a complaint against Flipkart due to the cancellation of his iPhone order. Some of the key grievances mentioned in his complaint were:

  • Order Cancellation Caused Loss: Flipkart canceled his iPhone order six days after placing it and paid Rs. 39,628 for it, causing a financial loss to the customer.

  • Mental Harassment: The sudden cancellation of the order he was waiting for caused great mental stress and harassment for the customer.

  • Subjected to Online Fraud: The customer felt that canceling the order intentionally after he paid for it amounted to subjecting him to online fraud.

  • No Proper Explanation: Flipkart did not give any valid reason for canceling the order, except for saying the customer was unavailable for delivery, which he denied.

  • Forced to Buy at Higher Price: After cancellation, the price of the same iPhone model increased by around Rs. 7,000. So, cancellation helped Flipkart earn more profit from the same customers.

The customer approached the consumer court seeking compensation for the mental agony caused by the unilateral cancellation of his order by Flipkart without any proper reason.

Flipkart's Response

Flipkart responded that it merely acts as an online marketplace and intermediary platform for sellers. It said all products on the platform are sold and supplied by independent third-party sellers, not by Flipkart itself.

In this case, the seller was International Value Retail Private Limited. Flipkart claimed it had no direct role in the complainant and seller transaction.

Flipkart informed the seller about the complainant's grievance. The seller then said its delivery person had made multiple attempts to deliver the iPhone, but the complainant was unavailable. Hence, the seller canceled the order, according to Flipkart.

However, the commission noted that Flipkart admitted to canceling the order unilaterally. It did not provide proof of the seller's multiple delivery attempts either.

Consumer Commission's Order

The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission of Central Mumbai held Flipkart guilty of unfair trade practices. Some key points of the commission's order:

  • The order noted that Flipkart unilaterally canceled the customer's iPhone order. The cancellation was done without informing or taking the customer's consent.

  • Flipkart claimed the order was canceled as delivery attempts failed, but the commission said Flipkart did not provide any proof of such delivery attempts.

  • The commission believed the cancellation was intentional to make extra profit as the cost of the iPhone had increased to around ₹7,000. So Flipkart wanted the customer to place a fresh order at a higher price.

  • Such unilateral cancellation without reason amounted to a deficiency in service and unfair trade practice by Flipkart as per the commission.

  • Though the customer received a refund, the commission said he needs compensation for mental harassment due to Flipkart canceling the order.

  • Hence, the commission ordered Flipkart to pay ₹10,000 to the customer as compensation for the mental harassment suffered due to the unfair cancellation.

Compensation to Customer

The consumer commission ordered Flipkart to compensate the customer for canceling his iPhone order. The customer placed an iPhone order on Flipkart's website and paid the amount. But later, Flipkart canceled the order without giving a proper reason.

This cancellation caused mental harassment and stress to the customer. He was waiting for his new iPhone, but the order was suddenly canceled. The customer had to follow up with Flipkart many times to get his money refunded.

Seeing the mental harassment caused to the customer, the consumer commission decided that Flipkart must pay him compensation. The commission ordered Flipkart to pay Rs. 10,000 to the customer for the mental harassment.

Additionally, the customer had to spend time, money, and effort attending the commission's hearings against Flipkart. For this, the commission also ordered Flipkart to pay Rs. 3,000 to the customer to cover any costs involved in the legal proceedings.

In total, Flipkart was told to pay Rs. 10,000 + Rs. 3,000 = Rs. 13,000 to the customer as compensation for canceling his order without a valid reason and causing him mental stress. This order shows that companies cannot harass customers and get away without paying for it. The consumer commission protects the customer's rights.

Lessons for E-commerce Companies

  • E-commerce companies should be responsible for placing orders on their platforms. Even if another seller fulfills the order, the customer sees the e-commerce firm as responsible.

  • Order cancellations should not be made unfairly just to make extra profit. Doing so harms customer experience and trust in the brand. Proper communication and approval are needed for cancellations.

  • Customer grievances around orders must be addressed sensitively. Simply refunding money is not enough, mental harassment due to unilateral cancellations should also be compensated.

  • Proof of failed delivery attempts should be maintained. Making claims without proof can damage credibility in consumer courts.

  • Intentional practices like canceling orders to charge higher prices later are considered deficiencies and unfair trade. Customer interests should be prioritized.

  • Courts view e-commerce marketplaces as more than just intermediaries. They expect proper oversight of sellers and responsibility in ensuring smooth services.

So, e-commerce firms must put customers first, avoid unfair practices for profits, and handle grievances and cancellations sensitively with proof to build long-term trust in the brand. Customer experience and protection should be a top priority.

Customer Rights and E-commerce Regulations

Online shopping has become very popular nowadays. We can buy phones, clothes, books, and more with just a few clicks. But sometimes problems also happen, like orders getting canceled. Customers and companies need to have laws to protect customers.

The case above shows that we need strong rules for e-commerce companies. The rules should say -

  1. Companies cannot cancel orders for no good reason. They should try all ways to deliver the product.

  2. If a cancellation is made, the customer should be properly informed and given the choice to buy at the same price.

  3. Customers should get compensation if the company does anything that causes mental stress, like canceling a big order.

  4. Companies must listen to customer complaints and solve problems quickly.

These rules will make online shopping safe and fair for buyers and sellers. All big companies must follow these rules properly. This will help businesses grow honestly. Customers will also feel safe while shopping online. Strong laws are needed to keep customers and companies happy.

What Should a Customer Do in Such Cases

In such cases where a customer faces mental harassment after the cancellation of an order, there are certain steps they can take to seek resolution:

  1. File a complaint with the consumer commission: The first step is to file a complaint with the appropriate consumer commission or forum. This helps initiate the legal process and seek redressal for the issue.

  2. Gather evidence: It's important to gather evidence related to the order and its cancellation. This includes documents like the order confirmation, cancellation message, payment receipts, and any other relevant communication with the seller or the platform.

  3. Highlight loss and mental stress: Clearly explain the loss and mental stress caused by the cancellation. Describe how it has affected you financially or emotionally, and provide any supporting documentation or statements that strengthen your case.

  4. Pursue the case: Pursue the case until a satisfactory resolution is achieved. Follow up with the consumer commission, provide any additional information or documents they may require, and actively participate in the legal proceedings.

By following these steps and presenting a strong case with supporting evidence, customers increase their chances of obtaining a fair resolution to the mental harassment caused by the cancellation of their order.

How to File a Case Against E-commerce Companies

If you want to file a case against an e-commerce company, here are the steps you can follow:

  1. Approach the consumer commission of your district: Identify the consumer disputes redressal commission or consumer forum in your district. This is the appropriate authority to handle complaints against e-commerce companies.

  2. Submit a complaint application: Prepare a complaint application detailing the issue you faced with the e-commerce company. Include relevant documents such as order receipts, payment receipts, communication records, and other evidence supporting your case. Along with your complaint application, pay the required court fees.

  3. Attend hearings and present your case effectively: Once your complaint is filed, you will be given a date for a hearing. Clearly explain the problems you faced, the losses or damages incurred, and the mental harassment you experienced due to the actions of the e-commerce company.

  4. Get orders enforcing your rights and compensation: If the consumer commission finds the e-commerce company guilty of unfair trade practices or deficiency in service, they may pass orders in your favor. These orders may include compensation for the losses or damages suffered and mental harassment endured. Ensure that you follow up on the implementation of the orders and receive the rightful compensation.

Please note that the information provided is a general guideline, and it is advisable to consult a legal professional for specific advice regarding your case.

Tips to Follow as an E-commerce Customer

As an e-commerce customer, following certain tips is important to ensure a smooth shopping experience. Here are some tips you can follow:

  1. Check cancellation policies before ordering: Before placing an order, read and understand the cancellation policies of the e-commerce platform. This will help you know the conditions under which you can cancel an order and the process involved.

  2. Insist on written confirmation for replacement orders: If you need a replacement for a defective or damaged product, always insist on getting written confirmation from the seller or the e-commerce platform. This will serve as proof and avoid any misunderstandings later on.

  3. Avoid verbal assurances and get responses through email: When communicating with customer support or the seller, try to get all important information and assurances in writing through email. Verbal assurances may hold little weight if issues arise later, but written communication can be used as evidence.

  4. Know your rights and escalate issues to appropriate forums: Familiarize yourself with your rights as an e-commerce customer. If you encounter any problems, such as cancellation without a valid reason or mental harassment, escalate the issue to the appropriate consumer forums or authorities. They can help mediate and resolve the matter.

Following these tips can protect yourself as an e-commerce customer and ensure a better shopping experience.

Lessons for E-commerce Companies

The recent ruling by a consumer forum ordering Flipkart to pay Rs 10,000 for mental harassment after canceling an iPhone order has important lessons for e-commerce companies. This case highlights the significance of fair trade practices, customer satisfaction, and effective dispute resolution in e-commerce.

Lesson 1: Transparency and Communication:

E-commerce companies should prioritize transparent and effective communication with their customers. In this case, Flipkart canceled the customer's iPhone order without proper explanation, causing mental harassment. Clear and timely communication can help prevent misunderstandings and build trust with customers.

Lesson 2: Customer Satisfaction:

Ensuring customer satisfaction should be a top priority for e-commerce companies. Flipkart's cancellation of the order resulted in loss, mental harassment, and the complainant being subjected to online fraud. E-commerce platforms should strive to provide a seamless shopping experience and promptly address customer grievances.

Lesson 3: Accountability for Third-party Sellers:

E-commerce platforms should take responsibility for the actions of their third-party sellers. Flipkart argued that it was merely an intermediary and the seller was responsible. However, the commission held Flipkart accountable for the cancellation, emphasizing the need for e-commerce companies to choose and monitor their sellers carefully.

Lesson 4: Fair Trade Practices:

The ruling highlighted the importance of fair trade practices. Flipkart's intentional cancellation to make an extra profit was deemed unfair and a deficiency in service. E-commerce companies should adhere to ethical business practices, avoiding practices that harm customers and undermine trust in the industry.

Lesson 5: Effective Dispute Resolution:

Having a robust and efficient dispute resolution mechanism is crucial for e-commerce companies. The consumer forum provided a platform for the complainant to seek justice and receive compensation. E-commerce companies should establish clear procedures to handle customer complaints and disputes, ensuring timely resolution.

So, The Flipkart case reminds e-commerce companies about the significance of transparency, customer satisfaction, accountability, fair trade practices, and effective dispute resolution. By incorporating these lessons into their operations, e-commerce companies can build stronger customer relationships and foster a trustworthy and thriving online marketplace.

Customer Rights and E-commerce Regulations

When it comes to e-commerce regulations, certain key principles protect customer rights. These include:

Right to Information

Customers have the right to accurate and transparent information about the products or services they purchase. This includes pricing, specifications, terms and conditions, and the seller's contact information.

Right to Choice

Customers should be free to choose from various products and services different sellers offer. They should not be subjected to unfair restrictions or forced to purchase from a specific seller.

Right to Privacy and Data Protection

Customers' personal information should be handled carefully and stored securely. E-commerce platforms should have clear privacy policies and obtain consent from customers before using their data for any purpose.

Right to Redressal

Customers can seek redressal through appropriate channels, such as consumer forums or dispute resolution mechanisms provided by the e-commerce platform, in case of grievances or disputes.

E-commerce platforms must comply with relevant regulations and guidelines to uphold these rights. They should have proper mechanisms to address customer complaints, provide easy access to customer support, and take prompt action to resolve issues. Additionally, sellers on these platforms should adhere to fair trade practices and fulfill their obligations regarding product quality, delivery, and customer service.

Overall, customer rights and e-commerce regulations are crucial in maintaining trust and confidence in online shopping. They provide a framework for fair and ethical business practices, ensuring that consumers are protected and can enjoy a safe and satisfactory shopping experience.

Conclusion

The recent case of Flipkart being ordered to pay compensation for mental harassment after canceling an iPhone order reminds consumers to be vigilant and cautious while making online purchases. It highlights the need for individuals to thoroughly research sellers and platforms, read reviews, and understand the terms and conditions before making a transaction. It is crucial to stay informed about consumer rights and regulations to protect oneself from unfair practices. By being alert and proactive, consumers can make informed decisions and ensure a safe and satisfactory online shopping experience. Stay informed, be cautious, and protect your rights as a consumer.

FAQs

FAQ 1: What is the process after a consumer commission order?

If unsatisfied, the company can file an appeal with the state/national commission. Otherwise, compensation will be paid as per the order.

FAQ 2: Can customers claim compensation for mental harassment?

Yes, consumer forums can award compensation for mental agony and stress caused by deficiencies. This is a recognized consumer right.

FAQ 3: What if the company doesn't pay the compensation amount?

Contempt of court proceedings can be initiated. The commission may impose fines or even jail terms on directors or persons responsible.

FAQ 4: Can customers claim compensation for other online order issues?

Yes, issues like delivery delays, wrong/defective products, misleading ads, etc, are grounds for compensation under the Act.

FAQ 5: What documents are required to file a case?

Complaint letter, ID/address proof, order confirmation, cancellation message, bank statement, correspondence with company, etc.

FAQ 6: Is there a limitation period to file cases?

As per the Act, the complaint should be filed within 2 years of the cause of action. However, commissions can condone delays on sufficient cause.


34 views0 comments

Comentários


© 2023 MonoidLabs Private Limited Copyright and rights reserved

1207 /343 & 1207 /1/343/1, 9th Main, 7th Sector, HSR Layout, Bangalore South, Bangalore- 560102, Karnataka 
CIN: U62091KA2023PTC180209

Kuttl

Blog

bottom of page