top of page
  • Writer's pictureSophia Satapathy

CaratLane vs Bluestone: Which Online Jeweler Provides a Better Buyer Experience?

Jewelry caratlane Bluestone

When it comes to buying jewelry online in India, two companies dominate the market - CaratLane and BlueStone. Both started around a decade ago and saw the potential in the growing e-commerce sector. CaratLane was founded in 2008, while BlueStone was launched in 2011. Since then, they have revolutionized how Indians shop for gold, diamonds, and other precious gems.

CaratLane and BlueStone have captured a major share of the online jewelry market through attractive designs, competitive prices, and aggressive marketing. Customers can browse various necklaces, bangles, rings, and more made with gold, silver, and diamonds on their websites and apps. Advanced filtering and customization options allow buyers to find the perfect piece for their unique style.

However, where a company truly differentiates is in how it treats customers after the sale. While pricing and designs draw users in initially, factors like delivery speed, response to issues, return policies, and quality checks build long-term loyalty. This article analyzes both CaratLane vs BlueStone on these important post-purchase parameters to determine which provides the superior buyer experience from order to ownership.

Customer Service and Grievance Redressal

Both CaratLane and BlueStone understand that excellent customer service is key to keeping customers happy and building brand loyalty in the long run. Here is a comparison of how the two companies handle customer queries, issues, and support.

Contact Options

Both companies provide multiple channels to reach out - customers can call, email, chat online, or send messages from the mobile apps. CaratLane has dedicated phone numbers listed clearly on its website. BlueStone's contact page is easier to find compared to CaratLane.

Response Time

As per several customer reviews, CaratLane usually responds within 24 hours on weekdays for most queries via email or chat. BlueStone takes up to 48 hours. However, depending on the complexity, both aim to solve issues within 3-5 days.

Quality of Support

 Most reviews suggest CaratLane agents are more patient and thorough in understanding the problem. They also try to find an amicable solution. In some cases, BlueStone agents followed a more standard process without tailoring the response to the specific issue.

Return/Refund Policy

Both offer a 30-day return period from the delivery date. CaratLane has a simpler process without additional conditions. BlueStone has some exceptions around jewelry needing to be in its original state, which could create confusion.

Replacement Guarantee

CaratLane stands out with a 1-year warranty or replacement guarantee for product issues. BlueStone does not mention any warranty or support after 30 days of purchase.

So, while both have improved over time, CaratLane leads in providing faster responses, more personalized customer support, and a clearer replacement policy, which are important for such high-value purchases.

Post-Purchase Marketing and Communication

Both CaratLane and BlueStone understand the importance of keeping customers engaged even after their purchase. Here is a comparison of their post-purchase marketing strategies:

Frequency of Messages

CaratLane sends about 1-2 monthly emails with new collections and seasonal offers. BlueStone communicates more frequently at around 2-3 weekly emails, which some may find overwhelming.

Relevance of Content

 CaratLane curates messages based on past purchases to improve relevance for customers. BlueStone messages sometimes seem more generic and need to account for individual preferences.

Unsubscribe Option

 CaratLane provides clear unsubscribe links in all emails and an option to select communication preferences on the website. BlueStone could simplify the unsubscribe process for customers who wish to opt-out.

Focus on New Launches

Both emphasize launching new collections through emails and notifications. But CaratLane balances it with reminders about after-sales services, which builds confidence in their brand.

So, while both companies aim to nurture customer relationships, CaratLane's communication strategy of less frequent but more personalized and relevant messages has been better received. This balanced approach avoids losing customers to spam but still drives engagement.

Quality Assurance and Standards

Both CaratLane and BlueStone understand the importance of quality assurance for jewelry products. Here is a comparison:

Quality Checks

CaratLane and BlueStone get their gold jewelry hallmarked from Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) approved assayers to ensure purity and quality. They conduct multiple checks like karatage test.

Quality Issues

 As per reports, CaratLane has fewer complaints about quality defects like incorrect karatage. BlueStone needs to strengthen quality checks to avoid such issues some customers report.


CaratLane aims to replace defective items within 2 weeks through their network of stores. BlueStone takes around 4 weeks due to their online model and high demand, as reported by a few customers.

Turnaround could be improved through better inventory management and customer service focus. Timely resolution builds trust, especially for expensive purchases like jewelry.

Both companies should continuously enhance quality standards through strict supplier audits and advanced testing tools to match the trust and craftsmanship of traditional jewelry stores. This will help them consolidate their leadership in the growing online jewelry space.

Privacy and Data Security

With the rise of digital transactions, customer data privacy and security have become a major concern for online businesses. As leading jewellery brands venturing into e-commerce, CaratLane and BlueStone must follow robust data protection policies to build customer trust. A brief overview of their practices is outlined below:

Customer Data Collection

CaratLane and BlueStone collect basic contact and financial information from customers to process orders and payments online. This includes name, address, email, and debit/credit card details. Email addresses may further be used to share latest catalogues and offers with prior consent.

Compliance with Privacy Laws

The companies maintain privacy policies in accordance with Indian data protection laws like the Information Technology Act of 2000. Sensitive customer payment details are securely encrypted, and access to such data is restricted only to authorized personnel. Norms around local data storage are also complied with as mandated by RBI for payment service providers.

Data Security Practices

So far, no major data breach incidents have been reported from either firm. However, constant upgrades are necessary to protect against evolving cyber threats. Two-factor authentication for login and encryption of data 'in transit' and at rest' using modern techniques could be implemented. Customers should also be informed proactively about enhanced security practices over time.

Data Usage

The companies may analyze Contact and transactional data internally to improve customer service and products and gain insights. However, as per their privacy policies, it should not be shared with any third parties without explicit consent. Strict compliance on data usage promises customers transparency in their data handling.

So, as reputed names in the jewellery sector collect valuable customer information, data protection should be CaratLane and BlueStone's top priority to enhance user trust in their digital platforms.

Legal Standards for Jewellery Quality in India

The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) enforces quality standards for jewellery in India.

  • Hallmarking regulations: All gold jewellery must be hallmarked, which means it is tested and certified as meeting purity standards by BIS-approved centres. Hallmarks show the purity level and identification marks. This ensures customers get the quality they pay for.

  • Purity standards: BIS sets minimum purity levels for gold, silver, and platinum jewellery. For example, the lowest purity allowed for gold jewellery is 14 carats (14k) or 58.5% pure gold. Higher carat levels like 18k or 22k signify more pure gold content.

  • Consumer protection: If a jewellery item does not meet the purity level advertised or has defects, consumers can claim compensation from the seller under the Consumer Protection Act. BIS will test the item to determine if quality standards were violated.

  • Penalties: Jewellers who violate purity standards or sell non-hallmarked goods face penalties like fines, imprisonment, or cancellation of registration with BIS. The penalties aim to discourage substandard products and protect unwary consumers.

In this way, BIS quality regulations and consumer laws work together to establish legal standards for jewelry, boost consumer trust, and maintain high-quality control in the Indian jewelry industry. Both businesses and customers benefit from a system that safeguards purity and excellence.

What To Do If You Suspect Your Jewelry Is Fake or Tampered With

Every online buyer's nightmare is receiving jewelry that turns out to be fake or damaged. While reputable retailers like CaratLane and Bluestone aim to avoid such issues, mistakes can sometimes happen. If you have concerns about the authenticity or condition of a piece, it's important to act quickly.

Start by having an independent jeweler inspect the jewelry in person. A professional can examine the craftsmanship and evaluate the metal and gemstone quality using tools like magnification and testing acids. They can identify hallmarks and certification stamps to determine if they are real gold or platinum or contain genuine diamonds/gemstones. Ask for a detailed written inspection report documenting any signs that may not be authentic.

Once you have the inspection report, contact the retailer immediately. Provide photos of the piece along with the report detailing the jeweler's findings. CaratLane and Bluestone have dedicated customer support teams that can be reached via phone, email, or chat to lodge your complaint. Understand the brand's return policy, which may require submitting claims within a certain window of receipt.

If the retailer needs to be more helpful or responsive, you can also file a complaint with state consumer protection agencies. Speaking to a lawyer about pursuing legal options may be advisable as a last resort. Proper documentation of the issue and following the appropriate processes can help secure your rights as a customer.


What is the difference between BlueStone and CaratLane?

BlueStone and CaratLane are both popular jewelry brands in India. The main difference is that BlueStone uses natural gemstones, which are rare and thus more expensive. CaratLane mostly uses simulated or cultured gemstones that try to mimic the look of natural ones but are more affordable.

Why is BlueStone so expensive?

BlueStone is expensive because it only uses rare and natural gemstones in its jewelry. Natural gemstones take millions of years to form inside the earth and can't be artificially made. Their rarity and natural formation process is what make them costly. BlueStone does not compromise on the quality or natural origins of the gemstones, so its jewelry tends to have a higher price point.

Why is CaratLane so cheap?

CaratLane jewelry seems cheaper than BlueStone because it uses manufactured or simulated gemstones instead of natural ones. Simulated gemstones like cubic zirconia and moissanite are made in labs and have the same optical properties as diamonds and other precious stones but at a much lower price. This is why CaratLane can offer jewelry in more affordable price ranges.

What is BlueStone famous for?

BlueStone is famous for using only the highest quality natural gemstones in all its jewelry designs. It is known for sourcing rare gemstones like blue sapphires, emeralds, and natural pearls. BlueStone has also become famous for its unique fusion of modern and traditional Indian designs using these natural, precious, and semi-precious stones.

Conclusion: CaratLane vs BlueStone

Both CaratLane and BlueStone are leading players in the online jewelry market. However, based on the analysis, CaratLane provides a better buyer experience.

CaratLane offers greater flexibility with both online and offline shopping options. It has a wider range of jewellery products as well as customization features. BlueStone, on the other hand, focuses only on online sales and has a limited range of designs.

While BlueStone leads in the online segment due to its competitive pricing and marketing, CaratLane's additional services, like warranty and greater physical presence, score over it.

For BlueStone to improve, it could consider expanding its product catalog and customization offerings. Adding warranties and increasing the number of offline stores would also help cater to different customer preferences. However, both companies are still growing and giving consumers quality options in the online jewellery space.

32 views0 comments


© 2023 MonoidLabs Private Limited Copyright and rights reserved

1207 /343 & 1207 /1/343/1, 9th Main, 7th Sector, HSR Layout, Bangalore South, Bangalore- 560102, Karnataka 
CIN: U62091KA2023PTC180209



bottom of page